Skip to main content

MasterChef The Professionals Final 2009 - Pt 2 (TV Review)


This blog post is brought to you by the letter "P" for "pain" as I have just sliced open a knuckle on a can of corned beef (mmm mmm, aren't I fancy?).

MASTERCHEF! The extravaganza continues. I've even made you a Spotify Playlist to soundtrack this post so you can relive every mother-loving moment.

How much India Fisher can we take? 90 minutes as it turns out. So Steve, Daniel and Marianne have just delighted a roomful of Michelin stars and the opening chords of the most overused song in the TV world* means it's time for the final cook-off - they must produce the best three courses of their career so far.

MasterChef Professionals Final (22)
L-R: Dan, Marianne, Steve

But first, an interminable X Factor style recap on the lives of each of the contestants begins. I find this excruciating partly because hello! they should be judging them on the quality of their food and not their family background, and partly because I've been there - I was on University Challenge a few years back (no recording exists, so don't ask) and the BBC filmed a similar segment about me. It was so mortifying just thinking about it makes me teary, so I'm sure Steve, Marianne and Dan didn't enjoy doing it either.

thankfully these flashbacks also deign to cover their culinary journey thus far.

Steve's greatest hits include his Smoky Egg, his Banana Cake with Guinness Ice Cream and his Sweet Shop on a Slate.

MasterChef Professionals Final (01)MasterChef Professionals Final (02)MasterChef Professionals Final (04)

Daniel's culinary highlights included his Beetroot and Curd Salad, his Tequila Dessert Trio and his Peach Melba.

MasterChef Professionals Final (07)MasterChef Professionals Final (06)MasterChef Professionals Final (05)

Marianne's story is soundtracked by the second most overused piece of music in TV**. If I hear that she's a private chef one more time I'll throw the remote at the telly. Her high notes included her Rhubarb Tarte Tatin, her High Tea Tower that Michel Roux Snr adored and her Mango Dessert Trio.

MasterChef Professionals Final (08)MasterChef Professionals Final (10)MasterChef Professionals Final (09)

Emotional recap over - Michel reminds us once more that Daniel, Steve and Marianne need to "cook out of their skins" and it's time for the MasterChef Showdown (cue shite remix of Morricone's The Ecstasy of Gold).

As they cook, Gregg and Michel roam around the MasterChef set like a pair of creepy uncles, alternating between trying to psyche out the finalists, and huddling together to whisper over-loud non sequiturs.

Marianne insists that there's no reason she shouldn't walk away with that crown - seriously dear, it's just a pseudo @ symbol - but she's the last to dish up when the crappy alarm that signals the end of their cooking time goes off.

Their menus in full:

  • Skate Tartlet, Poached Gull's Egg, Plum Tomatoes, Caper Butter
  • Poached and Roasted Guinea Fowl Supreme, Garlic and Chervil Stuffed Ballotine of Guinea Fowl Leg, Baby Leeks, Creamy Mash, Truffle and Madeira Jus
  • Rhubarb and Raspberry Souffle, Pink Pralines, Rhubarb poached in Grand Marnier, Clotted Cream

MasterChef Professionals Final (12)MasterChef Professionals Final (13)MasterChef Professionals Final (14)

  • Roast Quail with Morels, Asparagus, Quail Scotch Egg
  • Venison Loin, Potato Rosti, Watercress Puree, Roasted Beetroot, Red Wine Game Jus
  • Millefeuille of Raspberries and Bitter Chocolate, Lavender and Honey Ice Cream

article-1222223-06ED58E6000005DC-642_224x287_popuparticle-1222223-06ED58EE000005DC-14_224x287_popupMasterChef Professionals Final (17)

  • Grilled Asparagus, Iberico Ham, Poached Gull's Egg Dressing, Parmesan Foam, Pea Shoot Garnish
  • Turbot, Petits Pois Bonne Femme, Creamy Pea Bacon Veloute Sauce, Sauted Potatoes, Crispy Leeks
  • Warm Chocolate Fondant, Pistachio Ice Cream, Pistachio Tuile Biscuit

MasterChef Professionals Final (18)MasterChef Professionals Final (20)MasterChef Professionals Final (21)


Marianne's tart pastry's sublime and the egg perfect, but the butter's burnt. Her guinea fowl main course is a heavenly dream. Her use of pink pralines in the souffle is inspired (inspired by you, Michel, cos she nicked them off your chocolate creation dessert at the Michelin Star Dinner), but the clotted cream adds nothing. Oh, stop crying, love.

Steve's quail starter is stunning and Michel is flabbergasted at the thought of a quail Scotch Egg. Christ Michel, that rivals Kevin Pietersen's astonishment at the egg/asparagus combo. His venison main has bags of flavour and Michel cannot find fault. Steve's millefeuille shows skill and precision, "the raspberries are all the same height", chocolate not too bitter and pastry perfectly crisp. However, Michel hates the lavender and honey ice cream and I think "good" cos it's a cheeky rip-off of our mate Mat's dessert, winner of this year's non-professional MasterChef.

According to Michel, Daniel's starter is dressed "beautifully and elegantly". According to me, it looks like a plate of sick. And apparently the parmesan foam is too strong which makes me heave even more. Michel's not bowled over, though Gregg thinks it light and well-flavoured. Dan's turbot main has a glaring mistake though - its bad-tasting dark skin has not been removed. The fish itself is spot on though, as are all the accompaniments. As for his dessert, the tuile also appears to be "inspired" by Michel's chocolate creation - moreover there's fon-DONT fail as its insides are only a bit gooey rather than runny. The star of the show is Dan's pistachio ice cream.

MasterChef Professionals Final (19)
Dan's starter - you can even see the natty bits

So the judges have digested, cogitated and deliberated ...

Who's going to win?
Who's the future culinary genius?
And who's got that little bit extra?

There can be only one - and it's Smoky Egg Steve!

Today This Could Be-e the Greatest Day of Steve's Li-ife - sing it with me!

MasterChef Professionals Final (24)
MasterChef Professionals Final (17)

From the very start, Steve showed glimpses of rare and mad genius with his wood-smoked egg, his turbot with red wine bow tie in honour of Keith Floyd, his sweetshop on a plate.

I really think Gregg and Michel (pff, like Gregg had anything to do with it) made the right decision.

MasterChef Professionals Final (25)

And though this has no bearing on his cookery skills, Steve was modest and funny throughout the series.

He proved himself even more smish-able when during a live chat with MasterChef fans, his first message was "Dan, what's your favourite colour?" to which Daniel replied "Pink".

MasterChef Professionals Final (26)

Sigh, I love it when a nice guy wins (see further Mat Follas).

What Steve wins as MasterChef, apart from the delightful trophy, has always been a bit of a mystery to me. I'd love for him to be able to open his own restaurant off the back of this.

However, Steve is currently a chef at Launceston Place with the equally lovely Tristan Welch, so I recommend
in the meantime we all go stalk the pair of them try his food there.

*Unfinished Sympathy (Massive Attack)
**Perpetuum Mobile (Penguin Cafe Orchestra)

Read Part 1 here

Till we meet again ...

All screencaps/photos copyright BBC except the Q&A screengrab copyright The Times


Suz said…
I was so pleased that Steve won. I wanted him to win from the moment he did his smokey egg. The Keith Floyd tribute was sweet too.

This was very funny!
meemalee said…
@Suzler - Ha, the smokey egg did it for me too - I ran around the room going "Steve for the win!" as soon as I saw it :)
chumbles said…
Brill! I loved the creepy uncles comment; my own thought was that they rather reminded me of Waldorf and Statler! And, although I adore Marianne's voice, Steve's cooking had an essentially inspired quality that would have had him competing (probably successfully) in Great British Menu. Way to go!
BribedwithFood said…
I love the posts with added sarcasm and your Spotify playlist which has now been playing in the office for a couple of hours - I think my colleagues now hate me.

Steve's raspberry and chocolate millefeuille did it for me. Chocolate and raspberries always do it for me.
franmouse39 said…
Excellent as ever, meemalee. I loved (in a sadistic way) Marianne's wobbly lip when she was being judged. Thrilled that Steve won - smoky eggs all the way!
meemalee said…
@chumbles - Oh, I love the Muppet Show!

@Bribedwithfood - Hah, I have to wear headphones at work or I'd get stoned ;) Yep, the millefeuille was gorgeous looking.

@fran39 - Thank you! I almost got to meet Steve last night but seeing Tristan Welch (his boss) made up for it :)